"newsreader" <newsreader@charterinternet.net> wrote in message news:<10h9jvd6mec9eae@corp.supernews.com>...

[snip]

I argue that there is no known
evidence by which life would arise by supernatural intervention. 

I have no problem integrating your comment into my point, which is, we
have no reason to suppose there is ET life. I addressed the
materialistic possibility, and you addressed your concept of the
supernatural possibility. The conclusion is the same: There is no
reason to expect ET life.